ENT 640 Week 8 Blog: Harvesting – by Mary Schuler

After doing the due diligent, selecting, negotiating, and supporting to an early-stage company you are investing in, you are looking forward to seeing the result of your labor: harvesting – the final stage of angel investing business.

In agriculture definition, “harvesting” is the process of gathering a ripe crop from the field.

In business definition, “harvesting” is also known as the exiting or liquidity event. It is the process of cashing out of an ownership position in a company. It is an important part of an investment that involves capturing cash flows, reducing risks, and creating future options.

It would take at least one to ten years in general that the company has eventually grown to a value well beyond the initial price. It rewards hard work and needs to have an effective harvest plan. If the entrepreneur and the investor see the opportunity to harvest their investment by cashing out the fruits of their decade of sweat and tears, it can be harvested via several methods such as public offering of stock or through merger or sale of the company.

* Public offering is a company’s first offer to sell stock to the public. It is not limited to stock offerings but also bonds and a variety of other securities. Public offering is a way to raise capital for companies that need to grow and access cash. If a public stock offering is the first of its kind for a company, it is called an initial public offering (IPO).

* Merger is a corporate strategy of combining different companies into a single company to enhance the financial and operational strengths of both organizations.  Because mergers are difficult to implement, most ultimately take the form of an acquisition – the purchase of a weaker company by a stronger company.

* A sale is the transfer of title to a piece of property or performance of a service in return for compensation.

There are seven harvesting methods, in which there are five positive and two negative ones, according to the authors Amis, D. and Stevenson, H. Winning Angels: The 7 Fundamentals of Early Stage Investing. Pearson Education Limited, 2001. There are several alternative scenarios beyond IPO and acquisition with details and examples in the book but here are some basic definitions:

  1.  Walking harvest: the business investors and management team decides to start distributing profits (cash) directly from the business back to the investor. Companies that have little hope of achieving a positive exit also do not provide any current or anticipated investment return but not actually die are called the “living dead”.
  2.   Partial sale: is where the investor’s stake is sold to the company management, to another shareholder, or to an outsider even though the company itself is not sold.
  3. Initial public offering: The company sells a percentage of its shares which are listed on NASDAQ, NYSE or another exchange, creating a market for investors’ shares.
  4. Financial sale: The company is sold to a financial buyer who purchases it for its cash flows.
  5. Strategic sale: The company is sold to an industry buyer who buys it for strategic reasons, such as marketing synergies.
  6. Chapter 7: this is an option involved in harvesting a bad deal. Chapter 7 bankruptcy results in liquidation of business assets, and investors depending on their place in line, get little or nothing. In extreme circumstances, an investor may need to pay additional expenses to complete the process and shut down the business. Clearly Chapter 7 represents a worst-case scenario.
  7. Chapter 11: the company is re-organized, the value of the business and ownership are likely to change substantially, and investors will lose a significant amount of potential future investment upside. Following Chapter 11 re-organization, the investor may seek to solely get a return of capital or achieve a very modest investment return as a best-case scenario.

 

Resources:

Amis, D. and Stevenson, H. Winning Angels: The 7 Fundamentals of Early Stage Investing. Pearson Education Limited, 2001.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvest

http://www.invstor.com/information/go-big-dictionary/harvest-stage-definition

http://www.firstascentventures.com/blog/?p=16

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “ENT 640 Week 8 Blog: Harvesting – by Mary Schuler

  1. I thought your blog post on Harvesting was very informative. If someone who had not read “Winning Angels” and was unfamiliar with this process in the investment deal then this post would be very beneficial. Great post!

    Like

  2. Mary,
    Great overview of the Harvesting process. Your post outlines the options available to an entrepreneur to ensure his angel investor(s) gets their money back. I prefer the “Walking Harvest.” It allows the angel investor(s) to recoup their money and the company to continue on, ideally under the initial founder/entrepreneur. This creates a win/win for all involved.
    Great job.
    Nicole

    Like

  3. Mary,

    Great work! You know, I have to say that after reading the book and your post, the “walking harvest” kind of appeals to me the most. I’d like to imagine that after working for so many years on a business, I would get to keep it. So getting paid out each month sounds great to me. But then again, I realize this may never happen since there are so many variables that would have to align correctly to make it come true. For that reason, I suppose a good sale of the company might be most desirable. It’s hard to decide though when in a hypothetical world.

    Nicely written.

    Austin

    Like

  4. Mary,
    First I must say I love all your cartoon characters and especially this one. Clearly they had a good harvest. This definition of harvest was new to me and a perfect metaphor for startups since sometimes the exit is not bountiful. In my hypothetical cookie company and at my age I would like to see either a partial sale or strategic sale. It seems the company vision might have the best chance of surviving in either of those types of harvests.
    Cece

    Like

  5. Taking a company public creates a whole new set of challenges. Since the business is no longer privately owned, the value of the shares can increase or decrease significantly based on who is in a key leadership position, or what ideas people in the company are sharing publicly. As an investor, I’d want to have had a hand in a company for a while to determine whether or not I’d vote to go public. There are huge rewards in going public, though.

    Like

  6. You laid out a nice summary of the approaches to harvesting. I was amused to see the authors portray those companies that can’t quite achieve success or failure the living dead…doomed to walk the earth forever, apparently. There are worse fates though…the investors might not get their homerun out of it, but the business is apparently strong enough to hang on. The first rule of victory is to survive.

    After all, it took Intel fifteen or so years to figure out it was a microprocessor company.

    Like

  7. Mary,
    Great post – you really explained different options/ and /or scenarios that entrepreneurs/ investor could encounter. I guess I never thought about the actual years one will put into a business – but when you see that number it definitely equates to hard work. Likewise, because I maybe one who puts in a lot of work and may not want to let go- lol I think it probably would be wise to go with the walking harvest. At least if I am able to see what I put into it – it may comfort me. lol

    Thanks for sharing –

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s