ENT 640 Week 6 Blog: Negotiating – by Mary Schuler

As I hear from many business people, for some, negotiation is their most fun and favorite part when they are doing business. In angel investing, when it comes to negotiate the terms and price on an investment deal, the negotiation may or may not take place, depends on the circumstance and the stage. Due to using some winning tools and strategies that the investor either may not focus on the negotiating, they just asks someone else to do it for them or they really get involved in negotiation.

Negotiating is a time-consuming process and quite stressful for some people. However, “the negotiation need not be unpleasant”, said the authors Amis, D. and Stevenson, H. Winning Angels: The 7 Fundamentals of Early Stage Investing. Pearson Education Limited, 2001.

What are objectives of the negotiation?

  • The price
  • The structure of the deal
  • How much money they will invest
  • What role they will play, if any. < (in my mind this is so important)

What are the key issues which may need to be defined and agreed upon?

  • Valuation
  • Timing
  • Vesting
  • Control of the company
  • Modifying the Management team
  • Company Proprietary Rights
  • Multiple exit opportunities
  • Lock-Up Rights
  • And if they want to help in areas needed

There are also the angels and entrepreneur each will have their own additional wish list and or issues to bring to the table.

Why some angels who do not negotiate? Because

  • it may not be the time yet, and they don’t want to bring out the conflict that may affect the relationship;
  • sometimes they just put the negotiating off and wait till the second round to begin the negotiate.
  • “the angels will wait for an additional capital round where more significant capital is needed and then negotiate any special terms.”
  • some angels are not interested at the price or terms.
  • some get a front man (other investor or one of their advisors) to do the negotiating with the entrepreneur.
  • some angel investors send the entrepreneur on a mission, they want to see the reality of the entrepreneur’s working habit and abilities of approaching and handling business.
  • Some investors are always looking for signs that let them know the business that they would invest in is more than just a good idea.
  • some want to see the deep mutual relationship first that share long-term business partnership, the goals and getting improved value before writing a check.

Why some angels who do negotiate? Because,

  • “they are more likely to have an active role in their investment”. They would have great experience and would be able to lead the negotiation for the group of other investors.
  • they may found the balanced interest in the deal
  • some “like to negotiate to see how the entrepreneur thinks”
  • some “like to use the negotiation as a test”
  • some may just use one-time offer, take it or leave it option for the entrepreneur. They don’t want to spend too much time and energy on negotiation process.

 Resources:

Amis, D. and Stevenson, H. Winning Angels: The 7 Fundamentals of Early Stage Investing. Pearson Education Limited, 2001.

https://www.narach.com/investment/venture_capital_and_negotiation_issues.htm

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “ENT 640 Week 6 Blog: Negotiating – by Mary Schuler

  1. Mary,

    This chapter really opened my eyes to some of the more specific things that can be negotiated and how winning angels go about getting them. I’m sure we could all agree that being better negotiators would be very helpful in business and just about every other area of life, so it’s a beneficial topic!

    Austin

    Like

  2. Good write up on negotiating a deal. No matter whether I was an angel investor or entrepreneur I would have my attorney be the front man carrying on the negotiating conversations with the other side. I would definetely would want to be kept in the loop with my attorney but definetely not want to be the one face to face with other side carrying on conversations.

    Like

  3. Mary,
    Great post – I think and would hope that the negotiating part would be fun. I think it allows you to see potential team members personalities, weakness and strengths, – because this is the energy that you will be working closely with on a daily basis. So, I think one should look for effective, productive, knowledgeable and fun investors. I would love to meet one on one- but, it would be in my best interest to be represented by an attorney- as I always heard- there is a time and place for everything- first business- then fun. As much as I enjoy talking- I want to make sure the main focus of the meeting is not lost

    Thanks for sharing !

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s